Can Art Be A Good Investment (Part 2)

Last week we started talking about art as an investment rather than something being put out into the universe for social good or enrichment. I didn’t expect to write as much as I did so we made this a two-parter, rather than just have me lob on and on about art world intricacies.

Art has meant a lot to me in life and starting to collect art has been a really fun way to grow and diversify my investments. I’m super excited to help folks learn more about the ins and outs of how to invest in art as we finish up this series.

Now let’s wrap up learning about investing in art! Next week I’m going to do a deep dive into Crypto for 2024 that will probably be a muli-parter as well. Lots of stuff happening and lots more changes coming down the pipeline.

Last week discussed who the players were and how they maneuvered to make art the big business that it is. Now let’s get to the nitty gritty of money. How much? To whom? How do you know if something will appreciate? All those questions…

Section 5: Financial Considerations in Art Investment

Art investment is not just about acquiring beautiful pieces; it's also about financial prudence and understanding the economics of art ownership. The worst thing you could do as you start investing in art is to just throw money around willy nilly without thinking about what your buying power is and what appreciation level you’re aiming for.

Budgeting for Art Investment

1. Initial Purchase: Art can range from a few hundred dollars to millions. Determine your budget, keeping in mind that high-quality works by established artists are usually more expensive. You don’t have to be super wealthy to start. There are plenty of up-and-coming artists who are well-represented in major collections and have smaller pieces or works that fall well within most price ranges.

2. Diversification: Consider diversifying your art investments across different artists, styles, and periods. This can help mitigate risks associated with market fluctuations. Research (or have someone) prices of the artists or styles of works your looking at when putting together your budget - kinda like you would if you’re buying a house and looking at comps.

3. Long-term Perspective: Art investment often requires a long-term perspective. Unlike stocks or bonds, art may not provide immediate returns. You are playing the loooong game here. Think about art as your longest held asset when you are looking at your whole investment portfolio.

Understanding the Costs

Like everything, art ownership involves several costs beyond the purchase price:

1. Insurance: Artworks should be insured against theft, damage, and loss. Insurance premiums vary based on the artwork's value and risk factors. They can also vary based on your location. I was shocked at the premium changed when I moved some works from Ohio to San Francisco. RIP my insurance budget.

2. Storage and Maintenance: Proper storage and maintenance are essential to preserve the artwork's condition. This may include climate-controlled storage, framing, and conservation efforts. One way to limit these costs is to have the art properly framed. I cannot stress enough that Ikea frames, while affordable, are terrible for investment pieces.

3. Authentication and Appraisal Fees: Authenticating an artwork or getting it appraised can incur additional costs. Try to get all of this done before your purchase by negotiating with the gallery or seller.

4. Transaction Costs: Buying and selling art can involve transaction fees, including auction house commissions, gallery fees, or legal costs. These costs are when you start to get into the big leagues…but just be aware that they are there.

Investment Returns and Risks

A lot of things go into whether works are a good investment…so it’s pretty much just like venture capital.

Capital Appreciation: Art can appreciate over time, especially if the artist's reputation grows. However, like all investments, appreciation is not guaranteed.

Market Volatility: The art market can be unpredictable. Values can fluctuate based on trends, economic conditions, and changing tastes. Wars, recessions, and all that not-good stuff can easily stifle a market.

Liquidity Risks: Unlike stocks or bonds, selling art can take time. The art market is not as liquid as financial markets. If few people are liquid expect fewer bites when you’re trying to sell and plan accordingly.

Forgery and Fraud: There is a risk of investing in forged or misrepresented works. Due diligence and expert advice are crucial to mitigate these risks.

Tax Considerations: Be aware of tax implications, including capital gains taxes, when selling art at a profit. The tax man always cometh.

In Part 1 we discussed all the players in the sandbox and how to use them. Experts exist in the art world for you to use. Once you find folks that you respect and trust don’t be afraid to call on them for help.

Section 6: Strategies for Art Investment

Effective art investment involves more than just choosing the right pieces; it requires strategic planning and a deep understanding of the market. This is where your budget and taste collide. Building a collection that meets financial expectations and is aesthetically pleasing is the fun part!

Diversifying Art Investments

Mix of Styles and Eras: Diversify your portfolio by including a mix of traditional, modern, contemporary, and emerging art. This approach can reduce risk as different art segments may react differently to market changes.

Geographic Diversification: Consider artworks from different regions and cultures. This not only enriches your collection but also spreads risk across various global art markets.

Price Diversification: Invest in a range of artworks, from more affordable pieces to higher-value investments. This allows for flexibility in managing your portfolio.

Timing the Market: When to Buy and Sell

Market Research: Stay informed about trends and market shifts. Buying art during downturns and selling during peaks can maximize returns, though timing the market can be challenging.

Artist Career Stages: Investing in emerging artists can offer high growth potential, while established artists provide stability. Balancing these can optimize your investment strategy.

Long-term Approach: Art typically appreciates over the long term. Patience is often key to realizing significant returns.

Building Relationships with Galleries and Artists

Gallery Relationships: Developing strong relationships with reputable galleries can provide access to quality works and insider market knowledge. This is my preferred way to purchase art. A few curators know my taste and look out for works in my budget on a routine basis. I do less work and the transactions move smoothly.

Direct Artist Engagement: Engaging with emerging artists directly can offer investment opportunities before their work appreciates in value. I love working directly with artists too but remember that they’re busy making cool stuff so they don’t have as much time to be at your beck and call.

Art Fairs and Auctions: Regular attendance at art fairs and auctions can help build a network within the art community and keep you informed about new opportunities and trends. Things like Art Basel are fun, but chaotic. They also aren’t necessarily the best place to get deals. Sometimes mark ups are pretty substantial since there are exhibition costs for galleries and artists.

Leveraging Expertise

Art Advisors: Consider working with art advisors who can provide tailored advice and help navigate the complexities of the art market. A good (and trusted) art advisor can easily double the value of your collection.

Research and Due Diligence: Conduct thorough research and due diligence before any purchase. This includes verifying authenticity, provenance, and the artwork's condition. This is where trust, but verify comes into play.

Educational Resources: Utilize educational resources, such as art market reports, books, and online courses, to stay informed and make educated investment decisions. There are also some very good art commentators and essayists who do long-form deep dives on specific artists and markets.

Section 7: Legal and Ethical Considerations in Art Investment

Yay, now I get to talk about law stuff! Navigating the legal and ethical landscape is crucial for a successful and responsible art investment strategy. This section explores the key legal and ethical considerations that art investors should be aware of.

Legal Aspects of Buying and Selling Art

1. Provenance Verification: Ensure that the artwork's provenance is legitimate. This is crucial not only for valuation but also to avoid legal issues related to ownership and authenticity.

2. Contracts and Documentation: When purchasing art, proper legal documentation, including sales contracts and transfer of ownership papers, should be in place. These documents should clearly state the terms of sale, warranties, and provenance details.

3. Intellectual Property Rights: Be aware of the intellectual property rights associated with an artwork, especially for modern and digital art. This includes reproduction rights, which can be significant for photographers and digital artists.

4. Cultural and Heritage Laws: Some artworks, particularly antiquities and culturally significant pieces, may be subject to cultural heritage laws that restrict their sale and export. Please, I am imploring you, do not take cultural treasures from nations and regions looking to preserve their heritage. You look like an asshole when this happens.

5. Due Diligence on Legality: Conduct thorough due diligence to ensure that the artwork was not involved in illegal activities such as looting or art theft. Google Leonardo DiCaprio and Jho Low for a deep dive on why you should do this for annnnnny artwork you’re even given.

Ethical Considerations in the Art Market

Cultural Sensitivity: Be mindful of the cultural significance of artworks, especially those from indigenous or marginalized communities. Ethical investment respects the cultural heritage and moral rights of the original creators and communities. Again, just don’t be an asshole here.

Market Manipulation: Avoid practices that could be considered market manipulation, such as artificially inflating prices or engaging in speculative buying that can destabilize the market.

Supporting Emerging Artists: Investing in emerging artists ethically means ensuring fair compensation and recognition for their work, fostering a healthy and sustainable art ecosystem. Also, try not to have a whole collection of modern art made up of male artists. Can confirm that is not a good look.

Navigating the Digital Art Market

Oh yes, we are talking about NFTs. My mother is rolling in her grave for sure right now. The advent of digital technology has revolutionized the art market, introducing new forms of art and ways to invest. Recently, the majority of NFTs haven’t held their value but a few collections and works have. For NFTs the main thing to know is to avoid hype and look at the artistic significance.

Understanding Digital Art and NFTs

What’s the difference between digital art and NFTs?

Digital Art: This refers to artworks created using digital technology. Digital art ranges from digital paintings and illustrations to 3D models and interactive installations.

Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs): NFTs represent ownership of a unique digital item, often an artwork. Stored on a blockchain, they provide a certificate of authenticity and ownership, which is particularly valuable in the digital realm.

Risks and Opportunities in Digital Art Investment

Market Volatility: The market for digital art and NFTs can be highly volatile, with prices subject to rapid fluctuations. I cannot stress the volatility enough here. It can be super crazy out there so be careful.

Technological Risks: Investing in digital art involves understanding the technology behind it, including blockchain and digital storage. There are risks related to technological obsolescence and cybersecurity.

Authenticity and Provenance: While blockchain technology offers a new way to verify authenticity and provenance, it's important to understand its limitations and the potential for manipulation.

Legal and Copyright Issues: Navigating copyright laws is crucial in digital art, as digital reproduction and distribution are easier compared to traditional art forms.

Opportunities for Diversification: Digital art provides a new avenue for diversification in art investment. It appeals to a different market segment and is accessible to a wider range of investors.

Supporting Innovation: Investing in digital art means supporting innovative artists and new art forms, contributing to the evolution of the art world.

Best Practices for Digital Art Investment

Stay Informed: Keep up with technological advancements and market trends in digital art.

Expert Consultation: Seek advice from experts who specialize in digital art and NFTs to navigate this complex and rapidly evolving market.

Long-term Perspective: As with traditional art, consider a long-term perspective when investing in digital art, recognizing that market acceptance and valuation may fluctuate.

Ethical Considerations: Be mindful of the environmental impact of digital technologies, such as the energy consumption associated with blockchain.

Section 11: Future of Art Investment

I love making asinine predictions so here y’all go…

Predictions for the Art Market

Increased Digitalization: The trend towards digitalization is expected to continue, with more sales and exhibitions happening online. This shift could make art more accessible to a wider audience. I predict lower prices, more volatility, but more entrants into the market.

Global Market Expansion: The art market will likely see further expansion in emerging economies, with increasing participation from diverse cultures and regions. I don’t think the U.S. will be the market leader in art sales in the coming years. I think Asia is primed for a return to the top here.

Young Collectors and New Demographics: Younger generations, including Millennials and Gen Z, are becoming more involved in art collecting, bringing new tastes and perspectives. I think twee art is gonna come for us all.

Emerging Trends in Art Investment

Art as an Asset Class: Art is increasingly being recognized as a legitimate asset class, comparable to stocks or real estate, which could lead to more structured investment approaches. You can get loans against art collections now. I don’t know how much more official you can ask for.

Technological Innovations: Emerging technologies, like augmented reality (AR) and virtual reality (VR), could change how we experience and interact with art. VR is where I’m really excited to engage with conversations around art so if you’re building something there lemme know…

Data-Driven Investment Decisions: The use of data analytics in understanding market trends and valuations is likely to increase, leading to more informed investment decisions. Can’t wait until art goes quant.

Social and Political Themes: Art reflecting social and political issues is gaining traction, resonating with contemporary global narratives and appealing to socially-conscious investors.

Collaborative and Community Models: Collaborative models, like art investment funds or shared ownership schemes, might become more popular, democratizing art investment.

Impact of Technology on Art Investment

Blockchain and Provenance: Blockchain technology will continue to play a significant role in verifying the provenance and authenticity of artworks, particularly in the digital realm. Anyone building blockchain infrastructure tools for art, give me a call ASAP.

Online Marketplaces and Platforms: The growth of online art marketplaces and platforms is expected to continue, making art more accessible and creating a more transparent market.

Artificial Intelligence (AI) in Art Creation and Valuation: AI's role in art creation and valuation could lead to new forms of art and investment strategies. AI art will also have huge impacts on how we diligence art purchases.

Thanks so much for staying for the whole series. I really hope that you consider investing in art and making art a regular part of your life. Art can enrich and enliven our lives in ways we can’t even imagine until it’s happening. My journey as an art collector has made me fall in love with the world 100 times over so good luck on your journey!

And since I’m technically a VC I have to ask…

❤️ How Can I Help?❤️

👩‍💻 Want to learn more about regulatory and compliance within the startup ecosystem? Upgrade to get even more information

💸 So you want to become an LP in Vol. 1 Ventures? Fill out our LP interest form or check out Angellist here.

💰 Fundraising? At Vol. 1 Ventures we believe in openly and honestly sharing dealflow with our LPs and coninvestors. We send out deals weekly so let me help you raise

🗣️ Hiring? Get your job posting featured in Highly Regulated and/or on Vol. 1 Venture’s job board

💼 Need Regulatory & Compliance Help? Grab time with me for a 1:1 session or a full-day sprint

🚀 Advertise in my newsletter to get in front of 30,000 founders, investors, policymakers and industry professionals

XOXO

Stevie